A Comparison of Utopian Societies Essay

A Comparison of Utopian Societies Essay

Length: 878 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Ever since the worlds first nation state was created, the number one goal of its citizens has been to create the “perfect” society. To a majority of people in the novels Brave New World (c.1932) by Aldous Huxley and The Giver (c.1993) by Lois Lowry, a utopia and “perfect” society has been accomplished. But at a second glance, the world that Huxley creates and Lowry’s community are actually totalitarian dystopias with many secrets. The similarities of both novels are evident and some readers may make the conclusion that Lowry simply wrote a spinoff of Huxley’s novel. Yes, the similarities of these two novels are phenomenal, but so are the differences. Both novels take place in a futuristic society, yet both communities are distinctly different. Both novels feature characters of similar traits and personalities, yet the ways in which they were raised are contrasting. To some readers Huxley and Lowry’s novels seem considerably similar, but more in-depth readers can recognize the uniqueness of both novels.
Despite their similar subject manner, finding the similarities of the two novels requires a little more analysis then one might expect. Both novels have an individual who wants to change his society for the better. Lowry’s novel has Jonas, who uncovers the secrets and discovers the shallowness of “the community”(Giver1) and Huxley’s novel has John, who see’s the true corruption of “the Other Place”(BNW110). Both of these men set out to change their surroundings for the better and ultimately end up sacrificing themselves. Jonas and John are also Jesus figures in their novels. Both Jonas and John try to make their surroundings better for themselves and others. Although it is debatable whether or not either of them accomplishes ...

... middle of paper ...

...cific jobs at the “Ceremony of Twelve”(Giver45) based on their interests, attitudes and beliefs.
Aldous Huxley and Lois Lowry both wrote futuristic science-fictional novels in their hay day. The novels were written sixty years apart, yet have many similarities between them. Brave New World and The Giver have similar characters and similarities in the ways emotions are controlled. However these two novels also feature many differences; from the way children are brought up to the social structure of the societies. Huxley and Lowry created two masterful novels about the doom and gloom of the future. The two novels send out a warning to the world of the possible totalitarian state we may enter in the future. Both of the books are novels that may scare people with their perceptions of the future, but never the less are two historic, insightful, novels.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Utopian Societies in Literature

- Utopian Societies in Literature There are quite a few similarities between Terry Gilliam’s film, Brazil, and George Orwell’s novel, 1984. The protagonists in each story have very similar personalities, thoughts, and actions. Along with the connection between the main characters, the perspective governments in each story are extremely similar and, in general, the plot and overall feel of the stories are similar. While the novel 1984, and the movie Brazil compare greatly, so do they both compare with the film version of 1984, starring John Hurt....   [tags: Utopia Philosophy Philosophical Essays]

Better Essays
2373 words (6.8 pages)

Comparison Between The Maze Runner and Societies Essay

- Imagine a world where you are stuck in an arena, several times the size of a football field, and you are with about fifty teenage boys for as long as you live. Well, lucky for you, that is the world which is The Maze Runner. Yes, The Maze Runner, by James Dashner, is a fictional society, but there are real life civilizations that fall too, such as Germany in the Nazi era, Sierra Leone, and Ancient Rome. Societies can crumble down and burn due to corrupt leaders or government, lack of crucial resources, and a diminished security....   [tags: nazi era, fallen societies, corrupt leaders]

Better Essays
1658 words (4.7 pages)

Essay Gender Roles in Utopian Societies

- ... At one point, West asks if female roles have made any changes; Leete tells him that their roles have evolved. Leete tells West: “…‘Our women, as well as our men, are members of the industrial army, and leave it only when maternal duties claim them. The result is that most women, at one time or another of their lives, serve industrially some five or ten or fifteen years, while those who have no children fill out the full term’” (Bellamy, 267). Women are now working and making their own decisions; they can still be mothers when they need to be....   [tags: attraction, dominance, marriage]

Better Essays
1305 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Comparison of "The Giver" and "Brave New World"

- What one may think of as being a Utopia could be a dystopia to another. Lowis Lowry’s 1993 novel “The Giver” may seem like a remake of the 1932 “Brave New World” by Aldous Huxley given their similar plot lines, but these two novels also have their differences. Jonas and Bernard, the protagonists of the novels, both have an intelligence that wants to know more, that wants to know what is outside of this Utopian place they live in. Both Lowry and Huxley have very different family situations. Lastly, both these societies live in their own definitions of Utopia, but the roots of their government have a resemblance to Plato’s Republic....   [tags: Literature Review]

Better Essays
693 words (2 pages)

Utopian Societies Are Unrealistic And Unattainable Because Man Is Inherently Bad

- ... Their remains are processed into useful materials like phosphor. Community, identity, and stability are considered to be the main values in the World State” (Schermer). The effects of soma are: escape unpleasant situations/ ‘real life’, produces shallow feelings of well-being, no real happiness or fulfilment, distracts from any human effort or true mortality, promotes superficial pleasure-alienation from human life, keep social order- substitute for religion, and contentment (Schermer). “Soma is not an innocent or ideal substance...its dystopian face shines right through the surface of utopian happiness” (Schermer)....   [tags: Brave New World, Dystopia, Utopia]

Better Essays
1324 words (3.8 pages)

Utopia, 1984 Comparison Essay

- Research Paper: Love in Utopia, Brave New World and 1984 Love is without a doubt one of the most powerful emotions in the world. Most people in the world who have experienced this emotion know that with love, almost anything is possible. ¡§When in Love, the greater is his/her capacity for suffering, or anything else in that matter¡¨ (Miguel de Unamuno, The Tragic Sense of Life). The governments in both Brave New World and 1984 understand that eliminating love and loyalty is important in their continual process of domination over their societies....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
2259 words (6.5 pages)

Comparing Plato's Republic, More's Utopia, and Gurney's Dinotopia Essay example

- Plato's Republic, More's Utopia, and Gurney's Dinotopia   Throughout history, mankind has struggled to lead better lives and improve their society for future generations. What do we continuously attempt to improve. What kind of changes are we trying to institute. In other words, what is an ideal society. Many people have very diversified views about a perfect civilization. In Plato's Republic, Sir Thomas More's Utopia, and James Gurney's Dinotopia, three imaginary societies are described, each with its own peculiarities and highlights....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Better Essays
1391 words (4 pages)

The Quakers and Arts in Utopian Societies Essays

- The Quakers and Arts in Utopian Societies Today, we can still find many examples of past utopias. A utopia is an ideally perfect place, especially in its social, political, moral and legal aspects.1 They do not approve of any actions that are superficial and unnecessary. In addition to these beliefs, people from utopian societies are strong believers in God. Sharing many of these same ideals, the Quakers are a group with a strong faith. Despite the fact that Quakers feel art is a luxury and a frivolous thing that they should not take part in, many great artists and writers are members of the Quaker society....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Free Essays
1490 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Utopian Societies in Literature

- Utopian Societies in Literature A Utopian Society is based on the idea that all governmental tactics, laws, and social conditions are ideal to perfection. The relationship between authority and citizen coincide creating endless stability. Any abrupt disagreement regarding a radical idea can shift the equilibrium off balance, causing the population to become a threat to officials that could lead to a revolutionary plan. In the novels A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess and 1984 by George Orwell, both authors discuss the power and ability the governments hold to preserve order over their citizens....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2201 words (6.3 pages)

Literary Utopian Societies Essay examples

- Literary Utopian Societies “The vision of one century is often the reality of the next…” (Nelson 108). Throughout time, great minds have constructed their own visions of utopia. Through the study of utopias, one finds that these “perfect” societies have many flaws. For example, most utopias tend to have an authoritarian nature (Manuel 3). Also, another obvious imperfection found in the majority of utopias is that of a faulty social class system (Thomas 94). But one must realized that the flaws found in utopian societies serve a specific purpose....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Better Essays
1741 words (5 pages)