A Comparison of Sei Shonagon and Marie de France Essay

A Comparison of Sei Shonagon and Marie de France Essay

Length: 1393 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Comparison of Sei Shonagon and Marie de France

 
   Though more than two hundred years have separated Sei Shonagon and Marie de France, the scene is much the same. A courtly lady sits in a candle-lit room, with her writing hand poised above a book of parchment. Her face brightens in an instant of inspiration and she scribbles furiously onto the paper. This woman is closely associated with the royal court and is something of an anachronism, a woman author in a male-dominated world. The scene pictured here could have taken place in either Shonagon's late tenth century Japan or the twelfth century France of Marie de France. The differences that exist between these two authors are a result of their differing cultures and personalities. Marie de France writes as a product of her time, expressing herself through her characters, while keeping in mind the mandates of the church. Sei Shonagon is ruled by no such mandates and as a result wrote with merciless honesty. Accordingly, the structure, diction and imagery used by each author reflects her own distinct personality and values.

 

Sei Shonagon is most well known for her Pillow Book, a collection of her personal thoughts and observations during her time at court. The structure, or lack thereof, in this work gives the reader a peek at Shonagon's personality. She writes in short bursts, giving the mini-chapters such titles as "The Sliding Screen in the Back of the Hall," "Hateful Things," and "Oxen Should Have Very Small Foreheads." The titles are representative of her tendency to write at length on subjects that may seem inconsequential, or as the author admits in the last segment of the Pillow Book, "most trivial." In fact, these so-called trivial observations provide a s...


... middle of paper ...


...es and cultures. One author is governed by her strict faith and adherence to the church, the other by her own strongly-held opinions. Each woman's writing clearly reflects her own distinct personality and temperament: Marie de France, more eager and spiritual, Sei Shonagon, more satirical and opinionated. Both courtly ladies seem faithful to their own beliefs and reflective of their time and culture.

 

 

Works Cited

 

Sei Shonagon. The Pillow Book. Trans. Richard Bowring. The Norton Anthology of World Masterpieces. Expanded Edition. Ed. Maynard Mack. New York: W.W. Norton & Co. 1995. 2191-2218. All quotations are from this text.

 

De France, Marie. "Eliduc". Trans. John Fowles. The Norton Anthology of World Masterpieces. Expanded Edition. Ed. Maynard Mack. New York: W.W. Norton & Co. 1995. 1680-1692. All quotations are from this text.

 

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Lais Of Marie De France

- “The Lais of Marie De France”, written by Marie De France, is a collection of the most popular tales of the Medieval period. One of the tales named “Eliduc”, was about a knight named Eliduc who was the bravest and courtly knight anyone has ever seen. He was loved very much by the King of Brittany, where both he and the King resided. Because Eliduc was the popular and most loved knight, he had many enemies too, that were very jealous of him. So one day, the people who didn 't like Eliduc had told the king lies about him and were successful in changing the Kings ' perception about him, therefore, they had him banished for good....   [tags: Love, Marriage, The Lais of Marie de France]

Powerful Essays
1158 words (3.3 pages)

Lais Of Marie De France Essay

- Throughout the Lais of Marie de France there are several themes presented as central to the various stories. Some of these themes are present in all of the lais. One such example is that of courtly love and it’s implications. Courtly love being one of the more prominent themes in all of medieval literature, it is fittingly manifested in all of the lais as well. Another theme present in two of the lais is isolation. The theme of isolation plays a large role in the stories of Guigemar and Lanval....   [tags: Marie France]

Powerful Essays
1934 words (5.5 pages)

Essay on The Lais of Marie de France and Quickly-Budding Love

- Boom. The door flies open and a handsome knight runs into the room and yells, “Come my lady we must go now, for he is on his way”. The lady jumps to her feet and says “My love whom is on their way?” he responds, “your husband is on the way and he has heard of our romance”. The couple joins hands and quickly runs through the castle hoping that they are not seen. Suddenly the king jumps from a dark shadow, stops the couple in a sudden halt, and says, “Where do you think you are going?” With no response from the lady, the king reaches to his side and pulls a rope that releases a large bucket of acid onto the queen and her secret lover, which eats their bodies flesh within minutes only leaving t...   [tags: Lais of Marie de France, love, relationships,]

Powerful Essays
678 words (1.9 pages)

Essay about Solitude in Marie de France's Lanval

- Solitude in Marie de France's Lanval Marie de France’s “Lanval” is a Breton lai dominated by themes common to 12th century literature, which through its exploration of love, erotic desire, wealth, gender and community, tells the story of a young knight who finds himself caught between two worlds: his lover’s and his own. Forced to separate these societies by a warning in which his lover states, “do not let any man know about this…you would lose me for good if this love were known” (Lines 145-148), Lanval must keep his love a secret and exist apart from the Arthurian world into which he was born....   [tags: Marie de France Lanval Love Essays]

Powerful Essays
1378 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Romantic Love in Marie de France’s Poem, Lanval

- Romantic Love in Marie de France’s Poem, Lanval In her poem "Lanval," Marie de France shares a fantasy with her readers, telling the tale of a mysterious woman who journeys from a distant land to be with Lanval, a dishonored knight of King Arthur's Round Table. Marie's portrayal sets Lanval's mistress apart from the maidens and ladies in waiting at King Arthur's court, as she eclipses even Queen Guenever. Much like an editor of a modern woman's fashion magazine, Marie targets her audience of mostly aristocratic twelfth-century women....   [tags: Marie de France Lanval Essays]

Powerful Essays
645 words (1.8 pages)

Marie Antoinette And The French Revolution Essay examples

- Ideas suggesting equality between both genders went unappreciated by society during the French Revolution. Marie Antoinette welcomed these ideas by implying individualism. Scholars classified Antoinette as a rude tramp, basing their conclusions off primaries from the frustrated poor folk. These frustrated people had been cheated by their king and his financial advisors, who failed to create solutions to help the country’s ailing economy. The public looked to blame anyone who may have caused the present situation....   [tags: Marie Antoinette, Louis XVI of France]

Powerful Essays
1300 words (3.7 pages)

Marie Antoinette's Life and Achievements Essay

- Who was Marie Antoinette. A prestigious queen who was the face of France and a role model to her people, or a partying, rude woman with a luxurious life that would come to a tragic end. Ever since Marie Antoinette was 10 she always knew she would be a queen. Her mother Maria Theresa, who was the Empress of Austria, had arranged a marriage with King Louis XV; the grandfather of Louis XVI, who was to become the King of France, the man she was destined to marry. Together they would rule France and stay entwined in marriage through thick and thin, and anything that came their way....   [tags: france queen, marie antoinette, louis XVI]

Powerful Essays
1726 words (4.9 pages)

Marie Antoinette 's Influence On The French Revolution Essay

- ... Marie Antoinette would often attend operas, throw parties at Versailles, and gamble while the French public starved. Antoinette wore the latest and most expensive fashions while people in France were very poor. Marie Antoinette was one of France’s most controversial figures mostly due to the French’s view of her. The French’s public view on her in result led to her death. One of the most significant scandals that ruined Marie Antoinette’s already crippled reputation which helped lead to her death was the Affair of the Diamond Necklace....   [tags: Marie Antoinette, Louis XVI of France]

Powerful Essays
1171 words (3.3 pages)

Analysis Of Marie Antoinette 's Life Essay example

- Marie Antoinette 's life was, for the most part, consistent in lavish spending, and luxurious existence, excluding the last sections of her life, which consisted with metaphorically running from angry mobs, and the general French Revolution. Having her life, eventually, was cut short, by the hands of the angry French people, armed with a guillotine. This basic outline of her life is agreed upon by most all sources, and artistic representations across the media. With a story like this, without the modern coverage it could get in this day and age, leaves it pretty open ended....   [tags: Louis XVI of France, Marie Antoinette, Monarchy]

Powerful Essays
1422 words (4.1 pages)

The Lais Of Marie De France Essay

- In The Lais of Marie de France, the theme of love is conceivably of the utmost importance. Particularly in the story of Guigemar, the love between a knight and a queen brings them seemingly true happiness. The lovers commit to each other an endless devotion and timeless affection. They are tested by distance and are in turn utterly depressed set apart from their better halves. Prior to their coupling the knight established a belief to never have interest in romantic love while the queen was set in a marriage that left her trapped and unhappy....   [tags: Love, Romance, English-language films]

Powerful Essays
1210 words (3.5 pages)