Essay about A Comparison of Kate Chopin's The Awakening and Grand Isle

Essay about A Comparison of Kate Chopin's The Awakening and Grand Isle

Length: 1482 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Comparison of Kate Chopin's The Awakening and Grand Isle

    Grand Isle is the movie adaptation of Kate Chopin's 1889 novel, The Awakening. Turner Network Television (TNT) made the movie in 1991, and it stars Kelly McGillis as Edna Pontellier and Adrian Pasdar as Robert Lebrun. To say that this movie is based, even loosely, on The Awakening is an insult to Kate Chopin's colorful literary work. A reviewer from People Weekly calls it a "tedious melodrama" and sees it as Kelly McGillis's "vanity project" because she is star, producer, and narrator ("Grand Isle" 13). Grand Isle is an example of how Hollywood's ratings scramble can tear apart a striking piece of literature.

This movie misses the novel's subtle commentary on society completely. The first example is the role of Leonce Pontellier. In the movie, he is portrayed as a hateful, negligent husband. It is a temptation to make an easy villain of Leonce in the novel, but he is simply a male chauvinist, which was not an uncommon role in his society (Skaggs 88). Chopin was trying to address society as a whole, while the movie turns Leonce into the bully. Only the scenes where Leonce is angry with Edna are shown, leaving out his confusion and concern for her. The movie shows Leonce scolding Edna for neglecting the children, demanding her to come inside instead of sleep in the hammock, and becoming angry with her when he finds she has skipped her reception day. It does not show his genuine concern for her which he confides to his doctor or his confusion over her behavior. By creating a villain in Leonce, the movie misses the point Chopin was trying to address about her society in general.

Another aspect of the movie that falls short of Chopin's novel is the relatio...

... middle of paper ...

...dunes, and sunsets do not make up for the movie, but they help reduce the feeling that watching this movie was the biggest waste of time in the viewer's whole life. The People reviewer says, "Watch it with the sound off." ("Grand Isle" 13)

Any time a literary work is turned into a movie, the producers have a difficult task to make the movie as good as the novel. Grand Isle's producers, Turner Pictures and Kelly McGillis, failed miserably. Their dominant error was that they missed everything Kate Chopin was trying to say about her society and human nature in the novel. They twisted the story into a story of an affair, as opposed to a story of one woman's self-discovering journey.

Works Cited

Chopin, Kate. The Awakening. New York: Bantam, 1889.

"Grand Isle," People Weekly 13 Jul. 1992.

Skaggs, Peggy. Kate Chopin. Boston: Twayne, 1985.


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Kate Chopin 's The Awakening

- ... However, Mme. Reisz does not believe Edna has the potential to be an artist as she proclaims, “To be an artist includes much; one must possess many gifts—absolute gifts—which have not been acquired by one’s own effort” (85). Edna must grow more in order to become the artist Mme. Reisz envisions her to be. Nevertheless, Edna struggles to conform to what her friends expect of her. Adéle offers Edna a life full of responsibilities and hardships, while Mme. Reisz offers authentic expression. With a desire for more pleasure, Edna is unable to accept either of the lifestyles presented by her friends....   [tags: Wife, Woman, Kate Chopin, Marriage]

Powerful Essays
1256 words (3.6 pages)

The Awakening by Kate Chopin Essay

- Kate Chopin, inspired through her strong-willed widowed mother and grandmother, wrote inspiring stories of female heroines that were rejected by a society unwilling to accept Chopin’s risqué subjects. She was born into an affluent family on February 8th, 1851 in St. Louis, Missouri. She attended convent schools where she was strongly encouraged to pursue her writing career. She spent much of her free time by herself, in her attic, reading vigorously. Her mother and grandmother strongly encouraged her to think for herself and pursue her interests....   [tags: Edna Pontellier, female heroines]

Powerful Essays
1582 words (4.5 pages)

The Awakening By Kate Chopin Essay

- Kate Chopin’s writing throughout The Awakening is provocative in nature, designed to create thought in the readers by illustrating the deepest, darkest secrets that no woman of the time would admit to thinking. The novel brings into question the place women were put in the society of the time by linking Edna’s actions with her death. If Edna was not fond of her husband and wanted out of the marriage, why did she have to resort to suicide. Why wasn’t it acceptable for her to leave and start anew with a man she truly loved....   [tags: The Crucible, John Proctor, Elizabeth Proctor]

Powerful Essays
1775 words (5.1 pages)

Kate Chopin’s The Awakening, and Harriet Ann Jacobs’ Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl

- Although legality by and large determines the existence and prominence of oppression, the concept extends well beyond the scope of the law. Albeit the law can nullify legislation that entails aspects of oppression such as discrimination, the law can also permit, at times, for such things to exist. A legal system that is implemented and enforced within a society eventually becomes directly fused with the citizens and even life itself. It is interesting that contemporarily we most often discuss and reminisce the most important and most well-known events in our history; the most groundbreaking ones....   [tags: comparison]

Powerful Essays
1135 words (3.2 pages)

Comparing Edna Pontellier and Adele in Kate Chopin's The Awakening Essay examples

- Comparing Enda and Adele in The Awakening In The Awakening by Kate Chopin, the setting is in the late 1800s on Grand Isle in Louisiana. The main character of the story is Edna Pontellier who is not a Creole. Other important characters are Adele Ratignolle, Mr. Ratgnolle, Robert Lebrun, and Leonce Pontellier who are all Creole's. In the Creole society the men are dominant. Seldom do the Creole's accept outsiders to their social circle, and women are expected to provide well-kept homes and have many children....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
846 words (2.4 pages)

The Awakening, by Kate Chopin and The Cry of the Children, by Elizabeth Barrett Browning

- Abrams and Greenblatt (2006) explain that during the Victorian Era, women did not have the same rights as men. Women were not granted the right to vote until 1918, and married women were not permitted to own or handle their own property until the passage of the Married Women’s Property Acts (1870 – 1918). Men could divorce unfaithful wives, but wives could only divorce husbands committing adultery if their behavior included cruelty, bigamy, incest, or bestiality. Abrams and Greenblatt (2006) describe how women had limited educational and employment opportunities....   [tags: history, victorian era]

Powerful Essays
1284 words (3.7 pages)

Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston and The Awakening by Kate Chopin

- Novels that are written by pronounced authors in distinct periods can possess many parallels and differences. In fact, if we were to delve further into Zora Neale Hurstons, Their Eyes Were Watching God, and Kate Chopin’s novel, The Awakening, we can draw upon many similarities. Now of course there are the obvious comparisons, such as Janie is African American and poor, unlike Edna who is white and wealthy, but there is much more than just ethnicity and materialistic wealth that binds these two characters together....   [tags: paralells and differences]

Powerful Essays
1954 words (5.6 pages)

Use of Nature in Chopin's Awakening and Langston Hughes' Poems Essay

-       Langston Hughes and Kate Chopin use nature in several dimensions to demonstrate the powerful struggles and burdens of human life. Throughout Kate Chopin's The Awakening and several of Langston Hughes' poems, the sweeping imagery of the beauty and power of nature demonstrates the struggles the characters confront, and their eventual freedom from those struggles. Nature and freedom coexist, and the characters eventually learn to find freedom from the confines of society, oneself, and finally freedom within one's soul....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
2013 words (5.8 pages)

Essay on Symbolism in Kate Chopin's The Awakening

- Symbolism in Kate Chopin's The Awakening Chopin's The Awakening is full of symbolism.  Rather than hit the reader on the head with blunt literalism, Chopin uses symbols to relay subtle ideas.  Within each narrative segment, Chopin provides a symbol that the reader must fully understand in order to appreciate the novel as a whole.  I will attempt to dissect some of the major symbols and give possible explanations as to their importance within the text.  Art itself is a symbol of both freedom and failure.  In her attempt to become an artist, Edna reaches the zenith of her awakening.  She begins to truly understand pure art as a means of self-expression as well as self-assertion.  In a si...   [tags: Chopin Awakening Essays Kate]

Powerful Essays
1483 words (4.2 pages)

Kate Chopin's The Awakening Essay

- Kate Chopin's The Awakening Kate Chopin’s novel The Awakening expresses the difficulty of finding a woman’s place in society. Edna learns of new ideas such as freedom and independence while vacationing in Grand Isle. Faced with a choice to conform to society’s expectations or to obey personal desires for independence, Edna Pontellier realizes that either option will result in dissatisfaction. Thus, Edna’s awakening in Grand Isle leads to her suicide. Edna’s awakening occurs during her family’s vacation in Grand Isle....   [tags: Kate Chopin Awakening Essays]

Powerful Essays
1346 words (3.8 pages)